In February 2019, Governor Andrew M. Cuomo nominated Catherine E. Leahy-Scott as judge of the New York State Court of Claims. She was confirmed by the Senate in June 2019. Judge Leahy-Scott serves as judge with the New York State Court of Claims and Acting Supreme Court Justice in the 3rd and 4th Judicial Districts.
Prior to her judicial nomination and confirmation, Judge Leahy-Scott was appointed New York State Inspector General on May 2, 2013, by Governor Andrew M. Cuomo, after having served as acting New York State Inspector General since February 2012. She was reappointed inspector general in January 2015. Judge Leahy-Scott also served as acting welfare inspector general and the workers’ compensation fraud inspector general from 2012 and 2015, respectively, until her judicial confirmation.
As New York State Inspector General, Judge Leahy-Scott, among other matters, had authority over 200 state agencies, authorities, boards, and commissions covering more than 200,000 state employees working in the executive branch of State government. Judge Leahy-Scott’s office had oversight over State infrastructure projects including the construction of the Mario M. Cuomo Bridge, the Moynihan Train Hall project, and the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center expansion project, among others. Additionally, pursuant to federal law, the New York State Commission on Forensic Science designated Inspector General Leahy-Scott’s office as the governmental entity responsible for conducting independent external investigations of forensic laboratories across New York State. As inspector general, Judge Leahy-Scott issued over 100 public reports, the most notable issued in June 2016, entitled, Investigation of the June 5, 2015 Escape of (Incarcerated Individuals) David Sweat and Richard Matt from Clinton Correctional Facility. The subject matter of that investigation was made into a seven-part miniseries by Ben Stiller entitled Escape from Dannemora, where actress Bonnie Hunt played the role of then-Inspector General Leahy-Scott.
As the workers’ compensation fraud inspector general, Judge Leahy-Scott’s mandate included conducting and supervising the often-complex investigations of fraud and violations of laws, rules, and regulations pertaining to the operation of the workers’ compensation system. As the acting welfare inspector general, Judge Leahy-Scott’s jurisdiction included investigations of fraud, abuse, or illegal acts committed against public assistance programs designed to help those in need, as well as the investigation of complaints concerning the agencies and local social services districts that administer social services programs.
Previously, Judge Leahy-Scott served as an assistant attorney general for New York State investigating and prosecuting criminal matters with an emphasis on white-collar and public integrity cases; served for more than 13 years in the Columbia County District Attorney’s Office, eight as first assistant district attorney; served as a Columbia County Assistant Public Defender; was an assigned 18-b attorney; and worked in the general practice of law.
Judge Leahy-Scott received her bachelor of arts degree from Hofstra University, where she was named Hofstra University’s Woman of the Year in 1981, and her law degree from Hofstra University’s Maurice A. Deane School of Law, where in 2018 she was honored as a recipient of the Outstanding Women in Law award.
Currently, Judge Leahy-Scott, in addition to holding membership in several bar associations, serves as the co-chair for the New York State Court of Claims Equal Justice in the Courts Committee, member of the New York State Court of Claims Alternative Dispute Resolution Committee, and editor of the New York State Court of Claims newsletter, Sidebar.